FOR COMPANIES & HIRING TEAMS
BUILD A BETTER HIRING PROCESS
I’m Carolyn Illman, a former Amazon Bar Raiser and author of The Self-Aware Interview. I help companies figure out what they need from a new hire, ask questions that bring out useful examples, and give interviewers a consistent way to compare what they heard.
Hiring & Interview Process Consulting
If your team keeps adding interview rounds, gets feedback like “I liked them” or “I’m not sure they’re a fit,” or leaves the debrief wishing someone had asked a different question, let’s look at where the process is breaking down.
I’ll work with you to define what success looks like in the role, decide what each interviewer should assess, and build tools your team can use in its next round of interviews.
Depending on where you need help, we can:
Define what you’re hiring for. Clarify what the person needs to do well and what that looks like in practice.
Build interview questions and scorecards. Give interviewers questions tailored to the role and examples of what a strong answer might include.
Improve how your team makes decisions. Clarify who assesses what, how to document feedback, and what to do when interviewers disagree.
I can help you build a process from scratch or work with the one you already have.
Book an Intro Call Now
Case Study - How I Built a Unique and Robust Hiring Process for My Own Home Services Business
I put this methodology into practice when building the hiring process for my own home services company.
Challenge: A new home services business needed to hire trusted, experienced professionals quickly, without compromising on values, quality, or customer safety.
What We Built: End-to-end hiring process designed specifically for the business, including job descriptions, structured interviews and scoring rubrics, screening and background-check procedures, and hands-on skills assessments and quality standards.
Why: In an industry where trust is critical, the business wanted its hiring process to be a competitive advantage. The goal wasn't simply to fill positions, it was to consistently identify skilled professionals who aligned with the company's values, would represent the business well in customers' homes, and were likely to stay.
Results: The business launched with two fully vetted handy professionals within one month. Of the eight employees subsequently hired through the process, six remained with the company after 12 months; a 75% first-year retention rate. The business has also consistently earned 5-star customer reviews on Angi.
Working through a similar challenge? Book an Intro Call Now
The Self-Aware Interview for Hiring Teams
Two interviewers can hear the same candidate answer and walk away with very different impressions. One might hear confidence. Another might wonder what the candidate actually did. In this training, I use my Amazon #1 Bestselling book, The Self-Aware Interview, to help your team notice how their own communication styles and assumptions shape what they hear, then practice asking better follow-up questions.
Here’s one exercise we can do together. Everyone hears the same sample answer and writes down what the candidate actually said, what they inferred, and what they’d ask next. Comparing those notes gives the team a concrete way to see why they reached different conclusions and what evidence they still need.
Your team will practice how to:
Ask behavioral questions that get candidates talking about specific experiences.
Follow up when an answer is vague or it’s hard to tell what the candidate personally contributed.
Use shared criteria to write feedback and explain their assessments in a debrief.
I tailor the training to how your organization hires. We can pair selected reading from the book with live practice and build resources your team can keep using, such as a question bank, a scoring guide, or materials for onboarding new interviewers.
Ask About Team Training
Case Study - How a Consulting Firm Gave its Interviewers a Shared Approach
When "culture fit" started becoming a reason to disqualify candidates, and different interviewers had different ideas about what they were looking for, a consulting firm knew its interview team needed to get on the same page.
Challenge: Cross-functional stakeholders were approaching interviews differently, from the questions they asked to how they assessed candidates and determined "fit." The company needed a more consistent approach that would help interviewers gather the right information, evaluate candidates fairly, and make better-informed hiring decisions.
What We Built: A custom interview training curriculum based on the organization's hiring goals, designed to be used across teams and with future interviewers. The program included an interview question bank, guidance for evaluating candidate responses, and two one-hour interactive training sessions. The training was also recorded so the organization could continue using it as new interviewers joined the process.
Why: Consistency wasn't about making every interview identical. It was about giving interviewers a shared framework for what they were evaluating and how they gathered evidence, making hiring conversations more productive and reducing reliance on subjective ideas like "culture fit."
Results: The organization implemented the two-part curriculum as part of its interviewer readiness process, creating a repeatable training resource for both current and future interviewers. Managers started using the same language when discussing candidates, and new interviewers had a clear framework instead of simply learning by shadowing. “One of our senior partners remarked that this [curriculum] has been a significant step up in terms of content.” - Ben M
Need to get Your interview team on the same page? Book an Intro Call Now
Hiring Strategy Session
Need a second set of eyes on a hiring decision?
Bring me one hiring challenge and we’ll spend 90 minutes working through it together. We might review your plan for an upcoming interview, figure out why the candidates you’re seeing aren’t a match for the role, or identify what you still need to learn before choosing between finalists. You’ll leave with specific next steps you can put to work right away.